Friday, 14 March 2008

Regarding prostitution in New Zealand

Of relevance to debates elsewhere, I managed to track down an article on the reality of a brothel under New Zealand's new legal regime. Some relevant extracts (emphasis added by me):

Ford is one of a new breed of brothel keeper. When the Government legalised prostitution - estimated to be an $800-million-a-year industry - in mid-2003, it legitimised a trade which until then had been regulated by ambiguity.

Before 2003, running a brothel was neither fully illegal, nor fully legal. With the legal issues resolved, prostitution could now be treated like any other lawful business.

For supporters of the reforms, the hope was the Prostitution Law Reform Act would eliminate rogue operators and take sex out of the side streets into the safer, more regulated brothel environment.

Despite the fears and false promises, the only real change has been the fact that prostitution is now more visible.

Certainly there is no evidence to suggest a rise in the number of brothels or working girls since 2003. In Auckland City there are currently 25 licensed brothels, just a handful more than in 2003. North Shore and Manukau have two each, the same number as four years ago.

Nationwide, it is estimated around 6000 girls are making a living from prostitution, a number that has also remained steady since 2003.

Money - or the need for it - is still the number one reason women choose a career in the sex industry. For many, though, the rewards come at a huge emotional cost.


Initially, Ford's biggest challenge was finding "quality" girls.

Although working girls tend to be a transient breed, most flock to the busy parlours where they can be guaranteed five or six jobs a night. At $100 a time that means they can get by working only two or three nights a week.

On opening night, Ford had 14 girls on his books, well below what he required. "You can have a parlour in the Taj Mahal, but you're not going to make a go of it if you don't have decent girls," Ford said. "The parlour is all about your girls. They are your gold, they are your business." That said, they could also be a curse.

Many were unreliable and "lived close to the edge", Ford said. All the girls on his roster were employed as subcontractors, which meant they could come and go basically as they pleased.

"That's where the problem lies. Some days they just don't turn up and there's nothing you can do about it."


Former working girl Lacey remembers those dark days.

After two years on the game she has now moved into management, but says in those early days she also had doubts whether the club would survive.

Girls left because they couldn't afford to sit around for hours on end waiting for a client, she says. Yes, there was the potential to make $100 an hour but the reality was often quite different. While on a good night some girls might get up to 12 jobs, during a quiet shift they might not land one client.

And many of the girls paid a high price. Lacey says her stint virtually turned her into an alcoholic. The booze was the only way of masking having sex with someone who repulsed her, she says.

Clients ranged from 18 to 80 and came from a mix of backgrounds. Many were married, or in long-term relationships.

"It's men looking for a bit of variety. In some cases we help spark up relationships which have gone a little stale. It's not our place to judge whether the guys are married or not," Lacey said.

"That said, there's definitely some sick puppies out there who request all sorts of bizarre things. You wouldn't believe some of the things I've seen, or been asked to do."

It was always left up to each girl to decide which of the clients they had sex with, she said. "It is always the prerogative of the girl. Some girls won't have sex with certain types of men. That is their choice and there's no pressure from the club owner at all."

If a girl did not want to have sex with a particular client, but had agreed to take the job, she would use stalling techniques on them once in the room to use up the hour.

Most people would be surprised to learn that with 75 per cent of jobs, the girl never ended up having sex with the client. Some clients just wanted to talk, while others were content with a massage or spa.

"It's not always about the sex. There are other ways men like to be satisfied," Lacey said.

Some people also had the view that working girls catered for only the desperate and dateless, Lacey said. That couldn't be further from the truth.

During the day, the club catered mostly for retirees and businessmen looking for "a physical release" after a long boozy lunch. During the evening the club attracted a wide range of age groups, from young partygoers to labourers and executives.

But Lacey admitted it was a job that took its toll.

"It's a job that has a life span. But then I know girls who have been saying for the past seven years they were going to quit and are still doing it. The money keeps bringing them back. But the cost physically and emotionally is huge."

For a self-confessed parlour rat like Tony, who uses prostitutes about six times a week, it is about coming to a place where the women "treat you like the centre of the universe".

He enjoys the variety and the "no-strings-attached" nature of the sex.

"I don't have a steady girlfriend. I see nothing wrong with what I'm doing. I have built a relationship with many of these girls and that's what keeps me coming back," he said.


Caitlain's Corner said...

Interesting. Thanks for taking the time to post that.

Labrys said...

Thanks for the view from inside a "parlour" of girls.
I am of the opinion that legal prostitution is better than illegal, but it is obviously problematical regardless of legal status. Of course, here in America, moralists are all a-dither over the governor of New York engaging in high priced pro-play....

Phoenician in a Time of Romans said...

I am of the opinion that legal prostitution is better than illegal, but it is obviously problematical regardless of legal status.

Try to think of anything that isn't problematical.

I do have to take exception to the people on the Pandagon debate who seem to equate the reality of prostitution with Heinlein fantasies about "hetarae" - um, nope. I think it should be legal, and I'm not immune to some dubious tastes myself (think "cheerleader porn"), but that doesn't mean I don't recognise what we're talking about here has fundamental problems built in.

But people aren't angels, and the best we can do is deal with this fucked-up species as it is, rather than rail against them for not having wings. Legal prostitution works better for the workers than illegal prostitution. 'Nuff said.